Enamel pins are filled in by hand, so finding something in "perfect condition" is rare. Because of this, I'm more forgiving when it comes to the grading process. Grading is done by batch/design, so within any given batch, the least flawed pins will be A-Grade, and after that will be B-Grade
P4P
Due to the nature of P4P projects, these pins are considered standard grade and I won't spend as much time or scrutiny grading these, obvious flaws notwithstanding.
A-Grade
No defects can be seen at arm's length. Possibly may only be seen upon very close inspection. Possible micro-scratches from polishing. Glitter and Pearl may also have tiny visible flaws such as dust specks or differently colored glitter or dark specks.
B-Grade
Possible small imperfections such as smudges, scratched/scuffed enamel, rippled screen print, bubbles in the enamel, dust specks. Defects may be seen immediately from arm's length away.
*Please open your package and inspect your product as soon as you can after it has been delivered.*
Grading is time consuming and is all done by hand. If you feel as though you've received an incorrectly graded pin, please contact me and we can work together to fix the issue. I'm beyond excited that you would show your support to my store and I want to make sure my customers are getting the best service and the best quality I can manage :D Your satisfaction means everything to me.